1984 BYU football team had an incredible sense of good timing
1984 BYU football team had an incredible sense of good timing
Matt Zemek, BYU Cougars WireMon, June 8, 2026 at 3:36 PM UTC
0
1984 BYU football team had an incredible sense of good timing
If you talk to college football historians or to any older analyst who was working at the time, BYU's 1984 national championship remains a source of debate. Even those who think BYU deserved the 1984 title (as I do) would agree that BYU versus Washington would have been a terrific national championship showdown. It never happened, and in many ways that is what fuels the debate about that season. All of that aside, we can be sure of this: BYU did pick the best possible year to go 12-0, win the Holiday Bowl over a six-win Michigan team, and make it stand up enough to claim the trophy. Bill Connelly, before he moved to ESPN, wrote for SB Nation about the Cougars' exquisite timing:
"To win the national title as a mid-major your timing has to be amazing. Like BYU's. In the last 50 years, only one year has produced a No. 2 or No. 3 team in Est. S&P+ with a worse percentile rating than 1984: 1967. The fifth year of the 1980s produced no 99th-percentile team and only one above the 96th. That's pretty incredible. And in this year of amazing parity, BYU walked right through an open door.
"This was not the best BYU team of the LaVell Edwards era, not even close. In terms of Est. S&P+ percentiles, the Cougars hit 97.3% in 1979, 97.6% in 1980, and 96.9% in 1983, all better than 1984's 95.1%. But as I end up saying a lot, your best shot at an amazing breakthrough is simple consistency -- it's being good every year. Edwards and BYU established and maintained an incredibly high level for a WAC team, and when monstrous parity hit college football, the Cougars swooped in."
Advertisement
This is a reminder that a competitor's best season, performance, or analytics might not matter if the competition is better, but in 1984, the competition wasn't. BYU's timing was magical. The rest is history ... and a source of debate.
Contact/Follow @BYUCougarsWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of BYU Cougars news, notes and opinion.
This article originally appeared on BYU Cougars Wire: BYU football 1984 national championship was product of perfect timing
Source: “AOL Sports”
