Netflix vs Disney: Only One Is a Winner of The Streaming War
Netflix vs Disney: Only One Is a Winner of The Streaming War
Vandita JadejaTue, May 12, 2026 at 4:14 PM UTC
0
24/7 Wall St.Quick Read -
Netflix (NFLX) grew Q1 revenue to $12.25B with ad-supported sign-ups exceeding 60% in ads markets and advertiser count climbing 70% to 4,000 clients.
Disney (DIS) posted Entertainment SVOD revenue of $5.49B with operating margin reaching 10.6%, the first double-digit print, plus a record Experiences quarter of $9.49B driven by 5% higher domestic per capita spending.
Netflix is pursuing a leaner software-focused approach with buybacks and live events, while Disney is broadening its portfolio through parks expansion, ESPN’s NFL Network absorption, and IP-driven streaming profitability.
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 stocks and Disney wasn't one of them. Get them here FREE.
Netflix (NASDAQ:NFLX) and Disney (NYSE:DIS) just gave investors a side by side look at two very different streaming playbooks. Netflix posted a Q1 FY26 beat on revenue but a rare EPS miss, while Disney delivered its fiscal Q2 FY26 with a streaming profitability milestone, record parks revenue, and an ESPN reset.
Ad Tier Carries Netflix. Parks and SVOD Carry Disney.
Netflix grew Q1 revenue to $12.25 billion, up 16.2% year over year, with EPS of $1.23 versus a $1.34 estimate. The miss is messy on the surface, but net income included a $2.80 billion termination fee from walking away from the Warner Bros. deal. Co-CEOs Greg Peters and Ted Sarandos leaned hard into the ad tier, which drove over 60% of Q1 sign-ups in ads markets, while advertiser count climbed 70% to more than 4,000 clients. Ad revenue is on track to roughly double to $3 billion in 2026.
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 stocks and Disney wasn't one of them.Get them here FREE.
Disney's quarter looked broader. Revenue rose to $25.17 billion, up 6.5%, with adjusted EPS of $1.57 against a $1.50 consensus. Entertainment SVOD revenue jumped 13% to $5.49 billion, and segment operating income surged 88% to $582 million at a 10.6% margin, the first double-digit print. Experiences hit a record fiscal Q2 of $9.49 billion, helped by 5% higher domestic per capita spending.
Business Driver
Netflix
Disney
Main Growth Engine
Ad-supported tier, price increases
Parks, SVOD bundles, tentpole IP
Margin Story
31.5% operating margin trajectory
Streaming first hit 10.6%
Pure Play Streamer Versus a Sprawling IP Empire
Netflix is choosing focus. Walking away from Warner Bros., acquiring Ben Affleck's InterPositive GenAI filmmaking tools, and resuming buybacks ($1.3 billion repurchased in Q1, $6.8 billion remaining) all point to a leaner, software-style operator. Live events like the upcoming Tyson Fury vs Anthony Joshua bout add reach without changing the model.
Advertisement
Disney is widening the net, but smartly. New CEO Josh D'Amaro told investors, "Our creative and operational momentum drove strong quarterly results, and we continue to expect growth to accelerate in the second half of the fiscal year." ESPN absorbed NFL Network in exchange for a 10% noncontrolling stake, the Disney Adventure cruise launched in Singapore, and an Abu Dhabi park uses capital-light partners. Buybacks were raised to $8 billion-plus for FY26.
The Next Test Is Whether Margins Hold
Netflix guided FY26 revenue to $50.7 to $51.7 billion with free cash flow raised to roughly $12.5 billion. Yet shares are down 18.13% since the April 16 earnings report, and Polymarket traders place 54.5% odds on $85 as the May target. I read that as the market wanting proof the ad tier scales without subscriber churn.
Disney expects ~16% adjusted EPS growth in FY26, though Sports operating income may fall about 14% in Q3 on higher rights costs. The Zootopia 2 box office of $1.9 billion shows the IP flywheel still spins.
Why I Lean Toward Disney Right Now
Personally, Disney looks more interesting at this moment. Streaming has finally turned profitable, parks are setting records, and DIS is up 13.45% in the past month. Netflix is the cleaner business, but with a 23.62% one-year decline and soft Q2 guide chatter, I want clearer ad tier traction before adding. Growth investors may still prefer NFLX. I would change my view if Disney's sports margins slip further, or if Netflix's ad revenue closes in on that $3 billion bar early.
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 AI stocks
This analyst's 2025 picks are up 106% on average. He just named his top 10 stocks to buy in 2026. Get them here FREE.
Source: “AOL Money”
